Congress examines PFAS liability and cleanup regulations

Author

Charlotte headshot

Charlotte Mitchell Duyshart

Associate Legislative Director, Environment, Energy & Land Use | Gulf Coast Regional Forum
Andrew Nober headshot

Andrew Nober

Legislative Associate

Upcoming Events

Related News

1451944757

Key Takeaways

On December 18, the U.S. House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Environment held a hearing examining the current statutory and regulatory landscape for PFAS. The hearing follows a similar hearing held by the U.S. Senate Environment and Public Works Committee on November 19. Both hearings focused on how to ensure that cleanup regulations for per- and poly- fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) respected the concerns of passive receivers, especially municipally owned infrastructure. 

During the hearings, lawmakers expressed a bipartisan interest in legislation that would shield passive receivers from liability under federal law. NACo supports legislative action to protect public-interest and municipal passive receivers such as counties through a narrow liability exemption.

What are PFAS?

PFAS are a family of synthetic chemicals that have been manufactured and used in a variety of industrial and consumer settings since the 1940s. Commonly referred to as “forever chemicals,” PFAS can persist in the environment for decades and negatively affect human health. Exposure can occur in a variety of ways, including by breathing air containing PFAS, drinking water contaminated with PFAS and swallowing soil or dust contaminated with PFAS. 

On April 19, 2024, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) designated two common PFAS chemicals, PFOS and PFOA, as hazardous under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA; P.L. 96-510), also known as the Superfund law. Under CERCLA, the potentially responsible parties that manufactured or released PFAS chemicals into the environment can be held liable for cleanup costs. Despite having no part in manufacturing or distributing PFAS, counties could face significant compliance and remediation costs due to the presence of these chemicals at county-owned airports, in landfills and water systems.

Alongside the 2024 designation, EPA stated that its intention will be not to compel passive receivers such as counties to pay for PFAS cleanup costs under a policy of enforcement discretion. However, counties are not fully protected from liability as this policy is non-binding and could be revoked by future Administrations. The enforcement discretion policy also does not prevent other potentially responsible parties from seeking to hold counties liable to recover PFAS cleanup costs through CERCLA.

NACO PFAS HUB

Hearing Takeaways

In both hearings, lawmakers questioned witnesses about the impact of the CERCLA designation on local communities and economies, including whether EPA’s current discretionary enforcement policy would provide adequate long-term protection for passive receivers.  Republican and Democratic members from both chambers highlighted their shared belief that any legislative or regulatory fix should respect the “polluter pays” principle and avoid shifting cleanup costs onto ratepayer- or taxpayer-funded infrastructure or utilities.

At the U.S. Senate hearing, Chairman Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va) emphasized the committee would work to “enact a bipartisan solution to minimize future PFAS contamination, develop a clear path to destroy PFAS and protect passive receivers” and “provide a permanent statutory fix remove the burden of case-by-case settlements by providing lasting legal certainty.” In the U.S. House, both Energy and Commerce Chairman Brett Guthrie (R-Ky.) and Environment Subcommittee Chairman Gary Palmer (R-Ala.) spoke in favor of examining how the CERCLA designation is adversely impacting public-interest passive receivers.

NACo continues to advocate for legislative action that would codify a narrow liability exemption for counties and county-owned infrastructure under CERCLA for PFAS to ensure that local governments are not held financially responsible for cleaning up chemicals they had no role in manufacturing or distributing.
 

Related News

2165857864
Advocacy

U.S. Senate passes Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act

On Nov. 19, the U.S. Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA; S. 5653) after a 62-33 vote in the chamber. No further amendments were adopted besides a "manager's amendment" (ANS), which was released on Nov. 7 and approved during an earlier procedural vote. 

Union County, Ore. Commissioner Paul Anderes and Grace Donovan, executive director of Eastern Oregon University’s Rural Engagement and Vitality Center, present their Rural Leaders for Economic Mobility capstone project in May 2026. Photo by Charlie Ban
County News

Innovating Solutions Together: Turning Ideas into Results  

NACo CEO Matt Chase: "Every one of these counties started in the same place: a local vision, followed by a search for ideas. NACo builds the networks that connect county officials and other experts." 

electricity
County News

Counties play a growing role in the fight to lower utility costs for residents

County governments rarely have a direct role in the energy market, but a new NACo report finds that counties can often be most effective as advocates, helping lower residents’ utility costs by leveraging state programs, local partnerships and outreach.