Immigration policies exacerbate worker shortages, county officials say

The Immigration Reform Task Force meeting drew a large audience. Photo by Denny Henry.
Error message
In order to filter by the "in queue" property, you need to add the Entityqueue: Queue relationship.-
County NewsA packed room of county officials Sunday heard from immigration experts who said county officials frustrated by worker shortages in their communities need to tell their stories to members of Congress in order to make changes to immigration policy.Immigration policies exacerbate worker shortages, county officials say
-
County News Article
Immigration policies exacerbate worker shortages, county officials say
A packed room of county officials Sunday heard from immigration experts who said county officials frustrated by worker shortages in their communities need to tell their stories to members of Congress in order to make changes to immigration policy.
Industries including farming, construction, home healthcare, hospitals, hospitality and janitorial services depend on immigrant populations and are taking a hit due to ongoing confusion with immigration policies, panelists said.
Charlotte County, Fla. Commissioner Bill Truex, who chairs the Immigration Reform Task Force, introduced the speakers and Theresa Brown, director of Immigration Policy, Bipartisan Policy Center, moderated the discussion.
Panelists said that the immigration issue has been paralyzed by extremists in both parties, leaving behind frustrated, hard-working businesses and workers faced with a tangle of regulations.
“Politics is an impediment,” said Paul Schlegel, managing director for Public Policy at American Farm Bureau. He noted that the farming industry is facing competition for workers. “They’re leaving agriculture for construction.”
And builders are losing workers who can hop to other jobs for a raise in pay due to the worker shortage, said Ben Brubeck, vice president of Regulatory, Labor and State Affairs at the Associated Builders and Contractors. “They can’t finish buildings because the workforce is jumping from competitor to competitor, because there’s such a shortage.”
Hanna Siegel, managing director, New American Economy, said her group’s forte is telling the stories of the economics of the issue in communities across the country. She pointed out that immigrants are more likely to become entrepreneurs because they don’t have connections to find a job.
“Your voices are so important on Capitol Hill,” she said.
Brunswick County, N.C. Commissioner Patricia Sykes said that immigrants in her county do a good job when they work, but employers often don’t abide by laws and regulations, often paying cash to workers.
Siegel said counties can offer information to the immigrant community in their language to help them understand laws and regulations.
A packed room of county officials Sunday heard from immigration experts who said county officials frustrated by worker shortages in their communities need to tell their stories to members of Congress in order to make changes to immigration p2019-03-03County News Article2019-03-29
A packed room of county officials Sunday heard from immigration experts who said county officials frustrated by worker shortages in their communities need to tell their stories to members of Congress in order to make changes to immigration policy.
Industries including farming, construction, home healthcare, hospitals, hospitality and janitorial services depend on immigrant populations and are taking a hit due to ongoing confusion with immigration policies, panelists said.
Charlotte County, Fla. Commissioner Bill Truex, who chairs the Immigration Reform Task Force, introduced the speakers and Theresa Brown, director of Immigration Policy, Bipartisan Policy Center, moderated the discussion.
Panelists said that the immigration issue has been paralyzed by extremists in both parties, leaving behind frustrated, hard-working businesses and workers faced with a tangle of regulations.
“Politics is an impediment,” said Paul Schlegel, managing director for Public Policy at American Farm Bureau. He noted that the farming industry is facing competition for workers. “They’re leaving agriculture for construction.”
And builders are losing workers who can hop to other jobs for a raise in pay due to the worker shortage, said Ben Brubeck, vice president of Regulatory, Labor and State Affairs at the Associated Builders and Contractors. “They can’t finish buildings because the workforce is jumping from competitor to competitor, because there’s such a shortage.”
Hanna Siegel, managing director, New American Economy, said her group’s forte is telling the stories of the economics of the issue in communities across the country. She pointed out that immigrants are more likely to become entrepreneurs because they don’t have connections to find a job.
“Your voices are so important on Capitol Hill,” she said.
Brunswick County, N.C. Commissioner Patricia Sykes said that immigrants in her county do a good job when they work, but employers often don’t abide by laws and regulations, often paying cash to workers.
Siegel said counties can offer information to the immigrant community in their language to help them understand laws and regulations.
Hero 1

About Mary Ann Barton (Full Bio)
County News Editor & Senior Writer
Mary Ann is the County News editor and senior staff writer and is returning to NACo after previously working at the association. She comes to NACo after covering local news for Patch.com in Northern Virginia.More from Mary Ann Barton
-
Webinar
Prenatal-to-Three Peer Learning Network: Long-Term Strategies for Strengthening the Child Care Workforce (Urban/Larger Counties)
Mar. 22, 2023 , 2:00 pm – 3:00 pmUnable to attend? Watch the recording here. -
Webinar
Prenatal-to-Three Peer Learning Network: Long-Term Strategies for Strengthening the Child Care Workforce (Rural/Smaller Counties)
Mar. 21, 2023 , 2:15 pm – 3:15 pmUnable to attend? Watch the recording here. -
Blog
Webinar Recap: County Strategies to Recruit and Retain a Strong Behavioral Health Workforce
For county governments, a strong and fully staffed behavioral health workforce is key to supporting people living with behavioral health conditions. Like other sectors, county governments are experiencing a shortage in local behavioral health workforce. -
Blog
DHS and DOJ publish proposed rule on requirements for asylum seekers
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security, in conjunction with the U.S. Department of Justice, issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that creates a “rebuttable presumption of asylum ineligibility” for individuals who enter the United States who either fail to enroll in one of the Biden administration’s new parole programs or use the CBP One app to schedule their arrival into the country. -
Blog
The State of the Nation's Workforce: January County Explorer Update
County governments employ more than 3.6 million public servants.1 As one of the largest collective employers in the country, county leaders understand the importance of a thriving labor market. -
County News
Retirement snag lies in wait for some county workers, officials
The Windfall Elimination Provision is complicating retirement planning for county employees and officials.
-
Basic page
Community, Economic & Workforce Development Steering Committee
Responsible for all matters pertaining to housing, community and economic development, public works, and workforce development including the creation of affordable housing and housing options for different populations, residential, commercial, and industrial development, and building and housing codes. Policy Platform & Resolutions 2022-2023 2022 NACo Legislative Prioritiespagepagepage<p>Responsible for all matters pertaining to housing, community and economic development, public works, and workforce development including the creation of affordable housing and housing options for different populations, residential,
Contact
-
County News Editor & Senior Writer(202) 942-4223
Related Resources
-
Blog
Webinar Recap: County Strategies to Recruit and Retain a Strong Behavioral Health Workforce
For county governments, a strong and fully staffed behavioral health workforce is key to supporting people living with behavioral health conditions. Like other sectors, county governments are experiencing a shortage in local behavioral health workforce. -
Blog
The State of the Nation's Workforce: January County Explorer Update
County governments employ more than 3.6 million public servants.1 As one of the largest collective employers in the country, county leaders understand the importance of a thriving labor market. -
County News
Retirement snag lies in wait for some county workers, officials
The Windfall Elimination Provision is complicating retirement planning for county employees and officials.
-
Reports & Toolkits
ARPA Impact Report: An Analysis of How Counties are Addressing National Issues With Local Investments
With American Rescue Plan funds, counties are strengthening America’s workforce, addressing the nation’s behavioral health crisis, expanding broadband access, improving housing affordability and building prosperous communities for the next generation. -
Press Release
State and Local Government Groups Call for National Strategy to Address Urgent Workforce Needs
As public and private employers face a growing challenge to find the talent they need for a wide range of jobs, the leading organizations that represent state and local governments call for a national strategy to invest in the nation’s workforce. -
Reports & Toolkits
Counties and the American Rescue Plan Act Recovery Fund: Workforce Development
Across the nation, counties have experienced high unemployment rates during the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2020, over 300 counties experienced an unemployment rate of 10 percent or higher. The Recovery Fund provides counties the opportunity to bolster and strengthen the local workforce
More From
-
ARPA Impact Report: An Analysis of How Counties are Addressing National Issues With Local Investments
With American Rescue Plan funds, counties are strengthening America’s workforce, addressing the nation’s behavioral health crisis, expanding broadband access, improving housing affordability and building prosperous communities for the next generation.
Learn More