Harris County settles bail case, reforms system

Harris County Commissioner Rodney Ellis confers with NACo Past President Greg Cox at the 2019 Annual Conference. Photo by Denny Henry
Error message
In order to filter by the "in queue" property, you need to add the Entityqueue: Queue relationship.-
County NewsThe nation's third-largest county has eliminated bail for most misdemeanor offenses, setting up a major jail population reduction.Harris County settles bail case, reforms system
-
County News Article
Harris County settles bail case, reforms system
In a case Commissioner Rodney Ellis called as big as Brown v. Board of Education, Harris County, Texas has settled a lawsuit alleging the unconstitutionality of its bail system for misdemeanor offenses and committed to changes, in place since March, that eliminate money bond for misdemeanors.
The county will increase funding for public defenders, increase court hours for administrative work to clear or prevent warrants and a notification system to communicate with people charged with misdemeanors, all of which could cost $97 million to implement. The pending settlement of ODonnell v. Harris County ends a three-year battle brought by a woman who spent three days in jail because she couldn’t afford the $2,500 bail for driving without a valid license.
“This is the first time the equal protection clause and the due process provisions of the constitution were used as they relate to cash bail,” Ellis said. “It’s the same theory that Thurgood Marshall used to integrate the schools, something the Constitution didn’t bring about when it was written, that legislation had brought about.”
Learn More
National Symposium on Pretrial Justice summary report on proceedings
What's Happening in Pretrial Justice
Reducing Fines and Fees in County Justice Systems
Jail Population Management: Elected County Officials' Guide to Pretrial Services
Harris County spent almost $10 million in legal fees trying to fight the lawsuit, but it was inevitable, Ellis said, that the county was bound to lose.
It’s also one of the more substantial changes among the bail reform efforts playing out across the country, with state and local governments, judiciaries and prosecutors driving policy changes from different angles. In Harris County, more than 80 percent of misdemeanor defendants will be released, which Ellis acknowledges is already drawing opposition from the bail bonds industry.
“This isn’t an accident, there’s a lot of work over 10 years to go into something that seems like spontaneous combustion,” said Cherise Fanno Burdeen, chief executive officer of the Pretrial Justice Institute, whose organization tracks bail reform measures and lobbies others, including NACo on the issue. “What you’ve seen is a successful implementation of a set of recommendations by a coalition that included NACo and other organizations” following the U.S. Department of Justice’s 2011 National Symposium on Pretrial Justice.
“If you’re going to look at the charge, anyone charged with a misdemeanor, those are mostly probation-presumptive cases. Why are we putting anyone in jail in the first place? The minute they take a plea we’ll say ‘Great, now you’re out on probation.’ If they were dangerous Tuesday and not dangerous Wednesday, what changed?”
She said the ability to pay rarely matches the risk of reoffending, and flight risk is something that should be determined subjectively by a judge.
“The vast majority of people show up for court either when they were supposed to or they show up for having missed court,” she said. “It’s really a ‘missing an appointment’ issue and not a fugitive issue. Meanwhile, when a guy offers to put up $7 million – $8 million, everybody knows that figure means nothing to him, he can just fly to a non-extradition country.”
Ellis was empathic when the Harris County Commissioner’s Court voted on the settlement July 30.
“Nobody should be in jail because they’re broke, and it’s not just here, it’s all around the country,” he said.
https://www.youtube.com/embed/Tb2Z0T5hXnE
Dallas and Galveston counties are also facing heat for their bail practices. Dallas County District Attorney John Creuzot will no longer prosecute marijuana possession cases for first-time offenders outside of drug-free zones, misdemeanor criminal trespass cases that do not involve a residence or physical intrusion into property, and he launched other initiatives, including diversion programs for people caught driving on suspended licenses, expungement programs and re-graded probation guidelines.
Many changes are happening in some of the country’s largest counties. Harris County is the third-largest, with 4.65 million residents. The second-largest, Cook County, Ill. (5.2 million residents) also saw some recent changes to bail policy. In 2017, Chief Judge Timothy Evans instructed judges to set more reasonable bail amounts, including for felony charges, an area Harris County didn’t include. A report released in May 2019 comparing 15-month periods before and after that change showed no significant increase in public safety risk.
Elsewhere in the country:
- The mayor and Commission of Athens-Clarke County, Ga. eliminated cash bond for low-level offenses.
- Pima County, Ariz. has built a temporary screening facility next to its jail and county officials hope that by screening 400–500 misdemeanor defendants a month, the county will be able to save $1.5–$1.9 million a year in unnecessary detention costs.
- A federal injunction is requiring the independent city of St. Louis to give fair bail hearings within 48 hours of an arrest and a hearing within one week.
- Colorado Gov. Jared Polis signed legislation requiring courts to release people on personal recognizance who are charged with misdemeanors.
- New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu signed legislation prohibiting courts from using homelessness and substance misuse as the sole factors when considering how dangerous someone is.
The jury is still out in Jersey
New Jersey’s bail elimination effort is almost three years old, and while counties have seen their jail populations reduced, New Jersey Association of Counties Executive Director John Donnadio said it hasn’t added up to cost savings for his members yet.
“We’ve certainly seen a reduction in the county jail population, so from that point, it’s reached its intended purpose,” he said. “The counties are still processing the same number of prisoners. The majority of the cost-drivers at the county level were increasing county prosecutor office staffing, investing $50 million in hiring prosecutors, investigators; there was very little investment going into the county jails. We haven’t seen any jail layoffs, we may see some attrition in a few years, but … we’re still processing the same number of prisoners.
“We thought we might see some nominal cost-savings five years down the road, but we haven’t yet.”
Even though the measures haven’t produced savings yet, Donnadio said they were successful.
“It was, philosophically, the right thing to do. Operationally, there are other issues.”
For all the merits of community-based human service delivery, Donnadio said county jails were still helping get help for inmates on a regular basis.
“These same prisoners who couldn’t make bail were reviving mental health services in the jail and now they’re back in the community,” he said, “It’s something our jail wardens, our welfare folks, our human services folks are talking about. We’re struggling with what to do with the folks who were receiving mental health services in jail and now they’re not. We’re processing more prisoners than in the past but turning them around.”
Donnadio also said the technology upgrade costs might force an increase in court filing fees.
“If any states are looking at bail reform, I can tell you it’s going to cost a lot more money than they think it will.”
Fines, fees also cause problems
Bail isn’t the only financial consideration facing people in the justice system. Fines and fees can include traffic citations, penalties for conviction and court costs.
These fines are intended as a revenue source, in addition to a penalty, but low collection rates stymie that effort. Partially, it’s a matter of a disproportionate number of low-income people being affected. The Prison Policy Initiative found that the median monthly income for incarcerated people is less than $2,000. Texas Appleseed found that between 20-50 percent of people are in jail because of failure to pay fines.
And the effort involved in trying to recover those fines can be fruitless. Los Angeles County ended up spending $3.9 million to collect $3.4 million in probation fees.
NACo’s publication Reducing Fines and Fees in County Justice Systems offers a variety of approaches for holding people accountable for minor infractions while improving outcomes:
- Inquiring about a person’s ability to pay financial obligations
- Reducing penalties by a flat amount or by using a graduated scale
- Creating flexible payment plans
- Eliminating fees
- Prohibiting warrants and jail time for unpaid fees
- Adopting practices that can help minimize failures to pay or appear in court
The nation's third-largest county has eliminated bail for most misdemeanor offenses, setting up a major jail population reduction.2019-08-19County News Article2023-04-11
In a case Commissioner Rodney Ellis called as big as Brown v. Board of Education, Harris County, Texas has settled a lawsuit alleging the unconstitutionality of its bail system for misdemeanor offenses and committed to changes, in place since March, that eliminate money bond for misdemeanors.
The county will increase funding for public defenders, increase court hours for administrative work to clear or prevent warrants and a notification system to communicate with people charged with misdemeanors, all of which could cost $97 million to implement. The pending settlement of ODonnell v. Harris County ends a three-year battle brought by a woman who spent three days in jail because she couldn’t afford the $2,500 bail for driving without a valid license.
“This is the first time the equal protection clause and the due process provisions of the constitution were used as they relate to cash bail,” Ellis said. “It’s the same theory that Thurgood Marshall used to integrate the schools, something the Constitution didn’t bring about when it was written, that legislation had brought about.”
Learn More
National Symposium on Pretrial Justice summary report on proceedings
What's Happening in Pretrial Justice
Reducing Fines and Fees in County Justice Systems
Jail Population Management: Elected County Officials' Guide to Pretrial Services
Harris County spent almost $10 million in legal fees trying to fight the lawsuit, but it was inevitable, Ellis said, that the county was bound to lose.
It’s also one of the more substantial changes among the bail reform efforts playing out across the country, with state and local governments, judiciaries and prosecutors driving policy changes from different angles. In Harris County, more than 80 percent of misdemeanor defendants will be released, which Ellis acknowledges is already drawing opposition from the bail bonds industry.
“This isn’t an accident, there’s a lot of work over 10 years to go into something that seems like spontaneous combustion,” said Cherise Fanno Burdeen, chief executive officer of the Pretrial Justice Institute, whose organization tracks bail reform measures and lobbies others, including NACo on the issue. “What you’ve seen is a successful implementation of a set of recommendations by a coalition that included NACo and other organizations” following the U.S. Department of Justice’s 2011 National Symposium on Pretrial Justice.
“If you’re going to look at the charge, anyone charged with a misdemeanor, those are mostly probation-presumptive cases. Why are we putting anyone in jail in the first place? The minute they take a plea we’ll say ‘Great, now you’re out on probation.’ If they were dangerous Tuesday and not dangerous Wednesday, what changed?”
She said the ability to pay rarely matches the risk of reoffending, and flight risk is something that should be determined subjectively by a judge.
“The vast majority of people show up for court either when they were supposed to or they show up for having missed court,” she said. “It’s really a ‘missing an appointment’ issue and not a fugitive issue. Meanwhile, when a guy offers to put up $7 million – $8 million, everybody knows that figure means nothing to him, he can just fly to a non-extradition country.”
Ellis was empathic when the Harris County Commissioner’s Court voted on the settlement July 30.
“Nobody should be in jail because they’re broke, and it’s not just here, it’s all around the country,” he said.
https://www.youtube.com/embed/Tb2Z0T5hXnE
Dallas and Galveston counties are also facing heat for their bail practices. Dallas County District Attorney John Creuzot will no longer prosecute marijuana possession cases for first-time offenders outside of drug-free zones, misdemeanor criminal trespass cases that do not involve a residence or physical intrusion into property, and he launched other initiatives, including diversion programs for people caught driving on suspended licenses, expungement programs and re-graded probation guidelines.
Many changes are happening in some of the country’s largest counties. Harris County is the third-largest, with 4.65 million residents. The second-largest, Cook County, Ill. (5.2 million residents) also saw some recent changes to bail policy. In 2017, Chief Judge Timothy Evans instructed judges to set more reasonable bail amounts, including for felony charges, an area Harris County didn’t include. A report released in May 2019 comparing 15-month periods before and after that change showed no significant increase in public safety risk.
Elsewhere in the country:
- The mayor and Commission of Athens-Clarke County, Ga. eliminated cash bond for low-level offenses.
- Pima County, Ariz. has built a temporary screening facility next to its jail and county officials hope that by screening 400–500 misdemeanor defendants a month, the county will be able to save $1.5–$1.9 million a year in unnecessary detention costs.
- A federal injunction is requiring the independent city of St. Louis to give fair bail hearings within 48 hours of an arrest and a hearing within one week.
- Colorado Gov. Jared Polis signed legislation requiring courts to release people on personal recognizance who are charged with misdemeanors.
- New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu signed legislation prohibiting courts from using homelessness and substance misuse as the sole factors when considering how dangerous someone is.
The jury is still out in Jersey
New Jersey’s bail elimination effort is almost three years old, and while counties have seen their jail populations reduced, New Jersey Association of Counties Executive Director John Donnadio said it hasn’t added up to cost savings for his members yet.
“We’ve certainly seen a reduction in the county jail population, so from that point, it’s reached its intended purpose,” he said. “The counties are still processing the same number of prisoners. The majority of the cost-drivers at the county level were increasing county prosecutor office staffing, investing $50 million in hiring prosecutors, investigators; there was very little investment going into the county jails. We haven’t seen any jail layoffs, we may see some attrition in a few years, but … we’re still processing the same number of prisoners.
“We thought we might see some nominal cost-savings five years down the road, but we haven’t yet.”
Even though the measures haven’t produced savings yet, Donnadio said they were successful.
“It was, philosophically, the right thing to do. Operationally, there are other issues.”
For all the merits of community-based human service delivery, Donnadio said county jails were still helping get help for inmates on a regular basis.
“These same prisoners who couldn’t make bail were reviving mental health services in the jail and now they’re back in the community,” he said, “It’s something our jail wardens, our welfare folks, our human services folks are talking about. We’re struggling with what to do with the folks who were receiving mental health services in jail and now they’re not. We’re processing more prisoners than in the past but turning them around.”
Donnadio also said the technology upgrade costs might force an increase in court filing fees.
“If any states are looking at bail reform, I can tell you it’s going to cost a lot more money than they think it will.”
Fines, fees also cause problems
Bail isn’t the only financial consideration facing people in the justice system. Fines and fees can include traffic citations, penalties for conviction and court costs.
These fines are intended as a revenue source, in addition to a penalty, but low collection rates stymie that effort. Partially, it’s a matter of a disproportionate number of low-income people being affected. The Prison Policy Initiative found that the median monthly income for incarcerated people is less than $2,000. Texas Appleseed found that between 20-50 percent of people are in jail because of failure to pay fines.
And the effort involved in trying to recover those fines can be fruitless. Los Angeles County ended up spending $3.9 million to collect $3.4 million in probation fees.
NACo’s publication Reducing Fines and Fees in County Justice Systems offers a variety of approaches for holding people accountable for minor infractions while improving outcomes:
- Inquiring about a person’s ability to pay financial obligations
- Reducing penalties by a flat amount or by using a graduated scale
- Creating flexible payment plans
- Eliminating fees
- Prohibiting warrants and jail time for unpaid fees
- Adopting practices that can help minimize failures to pay or appear in court

About Charlie Ban (Full Bio)
County News Digital Editor & Senior Writer
Charlie is the County News digital editor and senior writer.More from Charlie Ban
-
County News
County library teams up with jail to offer resources to incarcerated individuals
The Salt Lake County Library teamed up with the county jail to educate inmates on how to navigate the library, including using employment resources. -
Reports & Toolkits
Planning Principles Toolkit
Tools, templates and strategic guidance for maximizing the impact of opioid settlement funds on your community’s opioid abatement priorities. -
Blog
The County Countdown – July 24, 2023
Every other week, NACo’s County Countdown reviews top federal policy advocacy items with an eye towards counties and the intergovernmental partnership. -
Blog
Community Mental Health Services May Support Reducing Jail Populations
The Stepping Up Initiative — supported by NACo, the American Psychiatric Association Foundation and the Council of State Governments Justice Center — assists county government efforts to reduce the prevalence of individuals with mental health conditions in the criminal legal system. -
County News
Urban, rural settings alike are ripe for wildlife interaction
While urban counties are seeing bears wander around a little more than usual, applications are due Aug. 1 for grants to assist wildlife crossing measures near highways. -
Reports & Toolkits
Medicaid Inmate Exclusion Policy (MIEP) Advocacy Toolkit
The Medicaid Inmate Exclusion Policy (MIEP), which denies or revokes federal health and other benefits, is a violation of the equal protection and due process clauses of the Fifth and 14th Amendments of the U.S. Constitution, respectively. This policy also places undue financial and administrative burdens on local jails and produces unfavorable health outcomes for individuals and communities. By contrast, the uninterrupted provision of health care helps our residents break the cycle of recidivism exacerbated by untreated physical and mental illnesses and substance use disorders.
-
Basic page
Justice & Public Safety Steering Committee
All matters pertaining to criminal justice and public safety systems, including criminal justice planning, law enforcement, courts, corrections, homeland security, community crime prevention, juvenile justice and delinquency prevention, emergency management, fire prevention and control, and civil disturbances.pagepagepage<p>All matters pertaining to criminal justice and public safety systems, including criminal justice planning, law enforcement, courts, corrections, homeland security, community crime prevention, juvenile justice and delinquency preven
-
Reports & Toolkits
Opioid Solutions Center
NACo’s Opioid Solutions Center empowers local leaders to invest resources in effective treatment, recovery, prevention and harm reduction practices that save lives and address the underlying causes of substance use disorder.Reports & Toolkitsdocument10123:30 pmReports & Toolkits<p>NACo's Opioid Solutions Center empowers local leaders to invest resources in effective treatment, recovery, prevention and harm reduction practices that save lives and address the underlying causes of substance use disorder.
Contact
-
County News Digital Editor & Senior Writer(202) 942-4210
Related Resources
-
County News
County library teams up with jail to offer resources to incarcerated individuals
The Salt Lake County Library teamed up with the county jail to educate inmates on how to navigate the library, including using employment resources. -
Blog
The County Countdown – July 24, 2023
Every other week, NACo’s County Countdown reviews top federal policy advocacy items with an eye towards counties and the intergovernmental partnership. -
Blog
Community Mental Health Services May Support Reducing Jail Populations
The Stepping Up Initiative — supported by NACo, the American Psychiatric Association Foundation and the Council of State Governments Justice Center — assists county government efforts to reduce the prevalence of individuals with mental health conditions in the criminal legal system.
-
Reports & Toolkits
Planning Principles Toolkit
Tools, templates and strategic guidance for maximizing the impact of opioid settlement funds on your community’s opioid abatement priorities. -
Reports & Toolkits
Medicaid Inmate Exclusion Policy (MIEP) Advocacy Toolkit
The Medicaid Inmate Exclusion Policy (MIEP), which denies or revokes federal health and other benefits, is a violation of the equal protection and due process clauses of the Fifth and 14th Amendments of the U.S. Constitution, respectively. This policy also places undue financial and administrative burdens on local jails and produces unfavorable health outcomes for individuals and communities. By contrast, the uninterrupted provision of health care helps our residents break the cycle of recidivism exacerbated by untreated physical and mental illnesses and substance use disorders. -
County Profiles
Opioid Solutions Center: Counties in Action
Learn how counties are demonstrating leadership and commitment to delivering effective abatement activities at the local level.