The benefits and challenges of needle exchange programs

Error message
In order to filter by the "in queue" property, you need to add the Entityqueue: Queue relationship.-
County NewsThe CDC shows participants in syringe exchange programs are more likely to enter drug treatment programs and more likely to stop injecting drugs, but the programs don't increase drug consumption.The benefits and challenges of needle exchange programsFebruary 20, 2019February 20, 2019, 7:00 pm
-
County News Article
The benefits and challenges of needle exchange programs
Orange County, Calif. is suing the state to block needle exchange programs in four of its cities. In Madison County, Ind., county commissioners have revived a syringe swap program after shutting down an earlier version in 2017.
In some communities where needle distribution has been controversial, its morality has been called into question for enabling drug users to break the law. In others, where programs have been welcomed, they’ve been hailed for stemming the spread of infectious diseases.
“It’s not that I’m unsympathetic in terms of trying to reduce the incidence of infection in the drug use population,” said Andrew Do, an Orange County supervisor.
“But we have to do it in a way that we don’t expose the rest of the population, the much bigger population, to even greater risk of harm.”
Do said the now-shuttered program was inadequately staffed and distributed far more needles than it collected. “Realistically, in my mind, I call it a needle giveaway program.
Because it allows each person to get up to 200 free needles a day.” That is, a person turning in one needle could get 20 more up to 10 times a day.
That imbalance, the supervisors held, led to a flood of discarded needles throughout the county. Do mentioned a clean-up effort of a homeless encampment along the Santa Ana River while the program was still operating.
“Within a stretch of less than half of a mile, we recovered 14,000 used needles.” Syringes were also being found tucked inside books at a local public library.
Public concerns about discarded used needles were one factor that led to Madison County, Indiana’s syringe exchange program being shut down in 2017 after two years in operation. The program, run by the county health department, had been created in response to a 30 percent rise in viral hepatitis cases in 2015.
In June, the program got a second chance when county commissioners voted unanimously to resume a modified version of the program — this time run by a nonprofit organization instead of by the county. In counties elsewhere across the United States, similar programs are running smoothly and showing positive results by at least one measure: Taking in more needles than they distribute. But that’s just one potential benefit.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, participants in syringe exchange programs are five times more likely to enter drug treatment programs. They’re 3.5 times more likely to stop injecting drugs. Research also shows that more than 90 percent of syringes distributed are returned. Generally, statistics show that the programs do not increase drug consumption.
The difference between contentment and conflict often hinges on how a state writes its laws allowing such programs to exist — and the extent to which they do more than just hand out needles.
Under California law, needle exchange programs can be set up by the county or the state, according to Supervisor Do. “On the one hand it provides for local input and control, and in the very next subparagraph, it says, by the way, the state department of public health can bypass all that and issue its own permit,” he said.
A former county deputy district attorney, he chaired the Orange County Board last year and recommended suing the state. A judge issued an injunction stopping the program until the case goes to trial in October.
In Kentucky, the State Legislature passed a law in 2015 to address rising rates of heroin use and overdose death. It enabled county health departments to establish Harm Reduction and Syringe Exchange Programs to address the spread of HIV and other blood-borne diseases. A 2017 state health department report ranked Kentucky as having one of the highest rates of hepatitis C in the nation, based on data from 2008 to 2015.
Henderson County is among the latest to approve a syringe exchange program. In the Blue Grass state, approval is needed from the county and city.
Clayton Horton is director of the Green River District Health Department, which encompasses Henderson. He said that while Henderson and neighboring Daviess counties aren’t at crisis levels regarding the opioid epidemic, it was an easy sell to get local buy-in.
“That required us to do a lot of education and do some advocacy with local governmental bodies …. We weren’t asking for resources; we’re weren’t asking them to pay for it,” he said. “But we were asking them to consent and agree and to trust us and to trust the evidence-based practice to set these up and run them.”
The CDC shows participants in syringe exchange programs are more likely to enter drug treatment programs and more likely to stop injecting drugs, but the programs don't increase drug consumption.2019-02-20County News Article2019-02-22
Orange County, Calif. is suing the state to block needle exchange programs in four of its cities. In Madison County, Ind., county commissioners have revived a syringe swap program after shutting down an earlier version in 2017.
In some communities where needle distribution has been controversial, its morality has been called into question for enabling drug users to break the law. In others, where programs have been welcomed, they’ve been hailed for stemming the spread of infectious diseases.
“It’s not that I’m unsympathetic in terms of trying to reduce the incidence of infection in the drug use population,” said Andrew Do, an Orange County supervisor.
“But we have to do it in a way that we don’t expose the rest of the population, the much bigger population, to even greater risk of harm.”
Do said the now-shuttered program was inadequately staffed and distributed far more needles than it collected. “Realistically, in my mind, I call it a needle giveaway program.
Because it allows each person to get up to 200 free needles a day.” That is, a person turning in one needle could get 20 more up to 10 times a day.
That imbalance, the supervisors held, led to a flood of discarded needles throughout the county. Do mentioned a clean-up effort of a homeless encampment along the Santa Ana River while the program was still operating.
“Within a stretch of less than half of a mile, we recovered 14,000 used needles.” Syringes were also being found tucked inside books at a local public library.
Public concerns about discarded used needles were one factor that led to Madison County, Indiana’s syringe exchange program being shut down in 2017 after two years in operation. The program, run by the county health department, had been created in response to a 30 percent rise in viral hepatitis cases in 2015.
In June, the program got a second chance when county commissioners voted unanimously to resume a modified version of the program — this time run by a nonprofit organization instead of by the county. In counties elsewhere across the United States, similar programs are running smoothly and showing positive results by at least one measure: Taking in more needles than they distribute. But that’s just one potential benefit.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, participants in syringe exchange programs are five times more likely to enter drug treatment programs. They’re 3.5 times more likely to stop injecting drugs. Research also shows that more than 90 percent of syringes distributed are returned. Generally, statistics show that the programs do not increase drug consumption.
The difference between contentment and conflict often hinges on how a state writes its laws allowing such programs to exist — and the extent to which they do more than just hand out needles.
Under California law, needle exchange programs can be set up by the county or the state, according to Supervisor Do. “On the one hand it provides for local input and control, and in the very next subparagraph, it says, by the way, the state department of public health can bypass all that and issue its own permit,” he said.
A former county deputy district attorney, he chaired the Orange County Board last year and recommended suing the state. A judge issued an injunction stopping the program until the case goes to trial in October.
In Kentucky, the State Legislature passed a law in 2015 to address rising rates of heroin use and overdose death. It enabled county health departments to establish Harm Reduction and Syringe Exchange Programs to address the spread of HIV and other blood-borne diseases. A 2017 state health department report ranked Kentucky as having one of the highest rates of hepatitis C in the nation, based on data from 2008 to 2015.
Henderson County is among the latest to approve a syringe exchange program. In the Blue Grass state, approval is needed from the county and city.
Clayton Horton is director of the Green River District Health Department, which encompasses Henderson. He said that while Henderson and neighboring Daviess counties aren’t at crisis levels regarding the opioid epidemic, it was an easy sell to get local buy-in.
“That required us to do a lot of education and do some advocacy with local governmental bodies …. We weren’t asking for resources; we’re weren’t asking them to pay for it,” he said. “But we were asking them to consent and agree and to trust us and to trust the evidence-based practice to set these up and run them.”
Hero 1
About Charles Taylor (Full Bio)
Charles Taylor is a special correspondent for County News.More from Charles Taylor
-
County News
Peers recognize Rock County, Wis. opioid settlement plan
Hearing from the people most affected by substance use disorder helped Rock County, Wis. craft a plan for the funds it will receive from the national opioid settlements. -
Blog
HHS releases guidance on the end of the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency
On February 9, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services released new guidance on the agency’s plan to end the federal COVID-19 Public Health Emergency declaration on May 11, 2023. -
Blog
DHS and DOJ publish proposed rule on requirements for asylum seekers
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security, in conjunction with the U.S. Department of Justice, issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that creates a “rebuttable presumption of asylum ineligibility” for individuals who enter the United States who either fail to enroll in one of the Biden administration’s new parole programs or use the CBP One app to schedule their arrival into the country. -
Blog
USDA releases new state guidance on Pandemic Electronic Benefits Transfer plans for summer 2023
On February 16, the U.S. Department of Agriculture Food and Nutrition Service released new guidance regarding Pandemic Electronic Benefits Transfer State Plans for the summer of 2023. -
Reports & Toolkits
The County Role In Long-Term Care
County governments play an essential role in ensuring the health and safety of older Americans and individuals with disabilities as key administrators of safety net programs and services. -
Blog
VA shares resources to assist with PACT Act outreach efforts
The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs began processing PACT Act benefit claims on January 1, 2023, and has been leading a nationwide outreach campaign to inform veterans, their families and survivors about the PACT Act and encouraging them to apply for the health care and benefits they have earned.
Related Resources
-
Blog
Addressing social determinants of health with GIS technology
Discover the transformative power of GIS technology in addressing social determinants of health and building healthier communities. -
Blog
HHS proposes new rule to improve availability of kinship foster care homes
On February 14, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Administration for Children and Families (ACF) announced a new proposed regulation that would allow child welfare agencies to adopt less burdensome licensing standards for all relative and kinship foster family homes. -
Blog
Pandemic-era SNAP benefits expire
On March 1, the temporary boost to Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits known as emergency allotments came to an end. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, these increased monthly benefits were authorized in 2020 by the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA, P.L. 116-127) and provided vulnerable households with additional grocery benefits to help mitigate the negative economic impacts caused by the pandemic.
-
Reports & Toolkits
Mental Health Awareness Month: County Participation Toolkit
This May, we invite the nation’s 3,069 counties, parishes and boroughs to participate in Mental Health Awareness month. -
Reports & Toolkits
The County Role In Long-Term Care
County governments play an essential role in ensuring the health and safety of older Americans and individuals with disabilities as key administrators of safety net programs and services. -
Reports & Toolkits
Legislative Toolkit for Counties: Priorities for Strengthening the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP)
This toolkit provides an overview of the county role in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), federal policy priorities for ensuring SNAP is effectively serving county residents and the current legislative and administrative outlook for program reforms.
Related Events
-
5Apr2023Webinar
County Leaders Championing Justice Efforts in Local Communities
Apr. 5, 2023 , 2:00 pm – 3:00 pm
More From
-
ARPA Impact Report: An Analysis of How Counties are Addressing National Issues With Local Investments
With American Rescue Plan funds, counties are strengthening America’s workforce, addressing the nation’s behavioral health crisis, expanding broadband access, improving housing affordability and building prosperous communities for the next generation.
Learn More